Université de Liège Réseau des Bibliothèques

Serveur institutionnel des thèses de doctorat

Nouvelles thèses
dans BICTEL/e - ULg
  • Kreusch, Marie - Graded-commutative nonassociative algebras: higher octonions and Krichever-Novikov superalgebras; their structures, combinatorics and non-trivial cocycles.
  • Simon, Ronnie Ernst - Lattice dynamics in antimony and tellurium based phase-change materials
  • Belleflamme, Alexandre - Detection of past and future atmospheric circulation changes over the North Atlantic region with the help of an automatic circulation type classification
Présentation Recherche thèse Dépôt thèse Accès
Page de résumé pour ULgetd-07092012-144506

Auteur : Demertzi, Athina
E-mail de l'auteur : a.demertzi@ulg.ac.be
URN : ULgetd-07092012-144506
Langue : Anglais/English
Titre : AIN'T NO REST FOR THE BRAIN. Neuroimaging and neuroethics in dialogue for patients with disorders of consciousness
Intitulé du diplôme : Doctorat en sciences médicales
Département : Médecine - Département des sciences cliniques
Jury :
Nom : Titre :
CLEEREMANS, Axel Membre du jury/Committee Member
GOEBEL, Rainer Membre du jury/Committee Member
GOLDMAN, Serge Membre du jury/Committee Member
MAERTENS DE NOORDHOUT, Alain Membre du jury/Committee Member
MAQUET, Pierre Membre du jury/Committee Member
NOIRHOMME, Quentin Membre du jury/Committee Member
MOONEN, Gustave Président du jury/Committee Chair
LAUREYS, Steven Promoteur/Director
Mots-clés :
  • fMRI/IRMf
  • resting state
  • neuroethics/neuroethique
  • pain/duuleur
  • disorders of consciousness/troubles de la conscience
  • vegetative state/état végétatif
  • self/soi
Date de soutenance : 2012-05-08
Type d'accès : Public/Internet
Résumé :

The sheer amount of different opinions about what consciousness is highlights its multifaceted character. The clinical study of consciousness in coma survivors provides unique opportunities, not only to better comprehend normal conscious functions, but also to confront clinical and

medico-ethical challenges. For example, pain in vegetative state/unresponsive wakefulness syndrome patients (VS/UWS; i.e. awaken, but unconscious) and patients in minimally conscious states (MCS; awaken, with fluctuating signs of awareness) cannot be communicated and needs to

be inferred. Behaviorally, we developed the Nociception Coma Scale, a clinical tool which measures patients’ motor, verbal, visual, and facial responsiveness to noxious stimulation. Importantly, the absence of proof of a behavioral response cannot be taken as proof of absence of pain. Functional neuroimaging studies show that patients in VS/UWS exhibit no evidence of control-like brain activity, when painfully stimulated, in contrast to patients in MCS. Similarly, the majority of clinicians ascribe pain perception in MCS patients. Interestingly, their opinions appear less congruent with regards to pain perception in VS/UWS patients, due to

personal and cultural differences. The imminent bias in clinical practice due to personal beliefs becomes more ethically salient in complex clinical scenarios, such as end-of-life decisions. Surveys among clinicians show that the majority agrees with treatment withdrawal for VS/UWS, but fewer respondents would do so for MCS patients. For the issue of pain in patients

with disorders of consciousness, the more the respondents ascribed pain perception in these states the less they supported treatment withdraw from these patients. Such medico-ethical controversies require an objective and valid assessment of pain (and eventually of consciousness) in non-communicating patients.

Functional neuroimaging during “resting state” (eyes closed, no task performance) is an ideal paradigm to investigate residual cognition in non-communicating patients, because it does not require sophisticated technical support or subjective input on patients’ behalf. With the ultimate intention to use this paradigm in patients, we first aimed to validate it in controls. We initially found that, in controls, fMRI “resting state” activity correlated with subjective reports of “external” (perception of the environment through the senses) or “internal” awareness (self-related mental processes). Then, using hypnosis, we showed that there was reduced fMRI connectivity in the “external network”, reflecting decreased sensory awareness. When more

cerebral networks were tested, increased functional connectivity was observed for most of the studied networks (except the visual).

These results indicate that resign state fMRI activity reflects, at least partially, ongoing conscious cognition, which changes under different conditions. Using the resting state paradigm in patients with disorders of consciousness, we

showed intra- and inter-network connectivity breakdown in sensory-sensorimotor and “higher-order” networks, possibly accounting for patients’ limited capacities for conscious cognition. We have further observed positive correlation between the Nociception Coma Scale scores and the pain-related (salience) network connectivity, potentially reflecting nociception-related processes in these patients, measured in the absence of an external stimulus. These results highlight the utility of resting state analyses in clinical settings, where short and simple setups are preferable to activation protocols with somatosensory, visual, and auditory stimulation devices. Especially for neuroimaging studies, it should be stressed that such experimental investigations tackle the necessary conditions supporting conscious processing. The sufficiency of the identified neural correlates accounting for conscious awareness remains to be identified via dynamic and causal information flow investigations. Importantly, the quest of subjectivity in non-communicating patients can be better understood by adopting an interdisciplinary biopsychosocial approach, combining basic neuroscience (bio), psychological-cognitive-emotional processing (psycho),and the influence of different socioeconomic, cultural, and technological factors (social).

Autre version :
Fichiers :
Nom du fichier Taille Temps de chargement évalué (HH:MI:SS)
Modem 56K ADSL
[Public/Internet] Thesis_ULg.pdf 10.91 Mb 00:25:58 00:00:58

Bien que le maximum ait été fait pour que les droits des ayants-droits soient respectés, si un de ceux-ci constatait qu'une oeuvre sur laquelle il a des droits a été utilisée dans BICTEL/e ULg sans son autorisation explicite, il est invité à prendre contact le plus rapidement possible avec la Direction du Réseau des Bibliothèques.

Parcourir BICTEL/e par Auteur|Département | Rechercher dans BICTEL/e

© Réseau des Bibliothèques de l'ULg, Grande traverse, 12 B37 4000 LIEGE